A TRUTH and reconciliation process should take place in the
diocese of Chichester, where, despite "enormous steps forward" in
safeguarding, the Church must avoid the temptation to give the
impression that "everything is all right."
This is the conclusion of the final report of the Archbishop of
Canterbury's Visitation of the diocese, the first such appointment
of Commissaries for more than 100 years.
Appointed in December 2011 by Archbishop Williams, the
Visitation, led by the former Bishop of Chelmsford, the Rt Revd
John Gladwin, was intended to help the diocese to "move away from
an appalling history" of failures in safeguarding (News, 30
December, 2011). An interim report, published last year, concluded
that "dysfunctionality continues to impinge upon the adequacy of
safeguarding within the diocese", and called for a "radical change
The final report, published last Friday, concludes: "We are
entirely satisfied that the Chichester diocese is committed, in so
far as it lies, to preventing any further abuse ever occurring and
to responding positively and effectively to the ongoing trauma that
will necessarily last very many years. We commend the enormous
steps forward that have already been made but we also stress the
necessity for the Diocese, both in its actions and in its
statements, to acknowledge the traumas still being suffered, and to
be suffered, by the survivors."
The report also suggests that progress has been made in
addressing the "dysfunctionality within the diocesan senior team"
identified in the interim report, which described "deep problems"
concerning the relationship between the previous diocesan Bishop,
Dr John Hind, and his team and the safeguarding advisory group. It
painted a picture of a divided diocese in which the Bishop's
authority was not uniformly recognised.
Since the publication of the interim report, a new diocesan
bishop, Dr Martin Warner, has been appointed and enthroned (News,
11 May), and the former Bishop of Lewes, the Rt Revd Wallace Benn,
has retired (News, 26 October). The final report concludes: "We are
satisfied that the senior team is a strong and coherent body
working well with each other." It also reports that "excellent
safeguarding practices" are now in place.
On Friday, Bishop Gladwin praised Dr Warner's engagement with
safeguarding and a "new style of leadership. . . I don't think
there is any area of the diocese which does not know it has a
diocesan bishop." He suggested that the diocese of Chichester
"might become beacon of hope which sets the standard for the whole
of the Church of England".
Last month, a survivor of abuse in the diocese welcomed a letter
of apology from Dr Warner, as "a clear signal that he's trying to
sweep in a change" (News, 26 April).
On Friday, Dr Warner said that the Visitation had "enabled us to
comprehend the damage done to so many people's lives. I hope that
all victims and those affected recognise in the words of the
Interim and Final Reports that their concerns have begun to be
heard, their determination recognised, and their extraordinary
courage honoured." He sought to reassure survivors yet to come
forward "that we will listen to and respond in any ways that are
appropriate to a report of abuse by priests or church workers".
While the report is more positive than its predecessor, the
Commissaries issue several warnings against complacency in the
diocese: "We do not intend . . . to give the impression that there
remains nothing further to do. Indeed, this is far from the case,
as the senior team recognises. We believe that it is inevitable
that there will be other survivors of the known abusing clergy who
have not felt able to come forward; we also recognise that there
may still be abusers who are as yet unrecognised."
The report repeats the interim report's warning that the law of
the Church of England is "presently not in line with the rest of
the civil law of employment" and its recommendation that "urgent
consideration should be made to amending the Clergy Discipline
Measure 2003 to permit the compulsory suspension of any cleric
immediately a complaint of abuse which is not obviously malicious
Anne Lawrence, a spokeswoman for MACSAS (Minister and Clergy
Sexual Abuse Survivors), who was involved in the Visitation,
welcomed the report on Friday. She said that it marked "a change in
the position of the Church in respect of those who have been