THE Church Times
has always been a specialist weekly. It is natural for us to feel
irritated by attempts to simplify religion elsewhere in the media.
Among the more wearisome of these in recent years have been the
stories of decline, financial hardship, impending schism, abusive
priests, and so on. It is understandable when the church hierarchy
attempts to counteract this approach with an excessively positive
narrative of its own; but these PR forays can be just as wide of
the mark. The Church in this country has always been a patchwork of
stories, many inspiring, some not. There are movements and fashions
that, on occasions, alter the behaviour or thinking of many
churchpeople, though never all, and almost always more slowly than
commentators suggest.
Individuals or groups
with a narrow, sectarian interest are frequently represented in the
media as representing "Christians". There are three types of
culprit: the unscrupulous reporter or, more typically, broadcast
producer, who simply seeks good copy; the busy journalist who has
time only to contact those who are readily available; and the
"religious pundit", who has the spurious weight of some sort of
organisation behind him or her. Because these together have brought
religion in the secular media to such a low pitch, there is a
fourth culprit: the sensible, knowledgeable practitioner who
understandably puts other priorities above correcting false media
impressions.
In this light, we commend
the new Theos report on the supposed Religious Right in the UK. Its
authors examine the credentials of those organisations most often
cited as examples of a right-ward shift, and find, in sum, that
they have neither the support, the organisation, the connections,
nor the policies to constitute a political movement that
corresponds to the Christian Right in the United States, which is,
itself, experiencing the doldrums after the recent Republican
defeat. And yet these organisations are the source of the
persecution narrative that has now been accepted as the normal
experience of Christians in the UK.
We therefore recognise the sentiments behind this description of
these organisations by someone from one of the more mainstream
groups, the executive director of the Conservative Christian
Fellowship, Colin Bloom: "They are so marginalised where it matters
that they're irrelevant. They're only relevant to a lazy
journalistic clique that try and create a polemic for good TV or
good radio. . . They want to get the most extreme voices and say,
'you represent the Evangelical Christian Right' - and these people
are mad!"