IN A meeting I attended
this month with other women clergy, it was noted how, since the
General Synod had voted against the women-bishops Measure, many
priests had been contacted by "cultural Christians", people who had
until now attended only christenings, weddings, and funerals, and
possibly midnight mass with their families, but now either wished
to be involved, or simply felt that they could make contact with
the Church.
Many of the priests felt
inspired that, out of this difficult situation, we had been given a
rare chance to become relevant to people's lives again.
A majority of these
people probably form the 70 per cent in the 2011 Census carried out
by YouGov to complement the ONS Census (News, 14
December). There they described themselves as having been
brought up as Christian, but have sought spiritual sustenance
elsewhere, or not at all.
Although generations of
work have been dedicated to this ministry, if we are to grasp this
opportunity, we need to re-examine why people have not been able to
find what they are looking for in a tradition as rich as our
own.
THE most common reason
that people now give for not attending church regularly is that
they see religion as one of the main causes of destructive
behaviour, both in history and around the world today.
Religion is often in the
news, if not as the cause of conflict, then pervading or appearing
to condone unacceptable social or political situations. In the past
decade or so, perhaps since 9/11, many people seem to have become
more concerned that, in attending church, they might align
themselves with this record.
Some have, therefore,
searched for a God that is beyond organised religion, so that they
can simplify their faith and begin to relate to a transpersonal
divinity. When asked, many reply: "I am not religious, but I am
spiritual."
They have searched
through meditation, mindfulness, self-examination, alternative
healing, and westernised versions of Eastern traditions (the last
of which appear to have left aside their political histories).
Yet, in Western
Christianity, we have a long heritage of exploring spirituality,
vividly shown, for example, in the work of the Desert Fathers and
the monastic orders. We have generations of teaching on spiritual
experience, mindfulness, and a simple and yet profound unity with
the divine: works from Gregory of Nazianzus to Ignatius of Loyola,
and from Julian of Norwich to Bede Griffiths. So why is it that we
struggle to reach people in this way?
ONE person was asked
whether he would attend a meditation class at a church in his lunch
break. He replied: "No, because they would force their prayers on
me at the same time, and I don't trust them." I wonder whether we
have underestimated the trust that needs to be rebuilt for people
to be able receive what is inherently their own tradition.
It can be hard for us to
receive attacks and be blamed for corruption. But, if we are
frightened to enter the conflict - if we feel accusations can be
exaggerated, uninformed, unjust, or that people are digging up the
past, associating us with other religions, ignoring the terrible
things done to us, or missing the positive contributions - then we
are afraid to meet those who are wounded.
Our fear is as strong as
theirs, and we, too, are in need of remembering God, who is beyond
conflict, and forgives. A remembering that supports us to step into
ideas of betrayal and the desecration of the sacred will be painful
for us. But, with the support of a loving God, this step could help
both sides to listen to each other and to change.
THE second most common
reason that people give for not looking to the Church for spiritual
guidance is the distance they feel from the life of Christ. One
person who sought to reconnect with his church recently said: "I
just couldn't sit and listen about Jesus, who lived 2000 years ago
with all the different people of that time, and find it relevant to
my life. I found more meaning in spending time with my family."
Another said: "I was
asked to be a godmother, and thought I would start going again with
my niece, but when I had to say the vows, I couldn't do it. The
things we had to say were disturbing, and we were told we had to
believe completely in it all." Yet another said: "I didn't get why
the Old Testament readings could be so cruel, and why that was
something they would want to read out and respect."
Our tradition has a vast
body of teaching about the steps that can be taken before being
able to encounter the life of Christ. For example, an Ignatian
spiritual director has to assess people to see whether they are
ready for a 30-day silent retreat that prays through the life of
Christ. The spiritual director looks for faith in a loving God -
nothing more. Many, however, are sent away to prepare, and the
preparation can take years, if not a lifetime, before they will be
ready.
Doubt is not something to
fear. Neither is it something that has to be overcome in order to
live with Christ: it is something to be companioned. True
companionship seeks to find two things: a language that those whom
we accompany can relate to, and the willingness to watch for God at
work in their lives.
Perhaps if we were to
talk more to people who express such doubts about the Church -
asking them where or when they have felt a connection with
something greater, and if we were then willing to find grace in the
most unexpected answers - then we would meet them where the Spirit
was working in their lives, and support them towards finding a
loving God.
A FURTHER question is the relevance of our church community to
most people living in an area. A group of teenagers in one city
were found laying candles and cards in a street, where a friend had
fallen out of a window. They said that if the church could have
done a memorial service in the way they would have believed in,
"just spiritual", they would
have gone to it with
their friends; but they were told that they had to have certain
Christian prayers. They were turned away from the church because of
its insistence on particular forms.
What is remarkable about
this is the growing sense of community values. Lamp-posts are laden
with flowers marking the place where someone has died. Hundreds
helped to clear up their cities after the 2011 riots. The Olympics
had 70,000 volunteer Gamesmakers.
People are inspired to
rebuild their community; something that is at the centre of our
message. The Church has a strong record of charity work, but
perhaps we are being asked to step further into what is happening
on the street, and join in.
WE NEED to grapple harder
with the question of how we might build a bridge wide enough for
this large part of the population to find guidance for their
spiritual life in what is their own heritage. Many feel that if our
services and outreach (such as feeding the homeless or youth work)
does not involve discussing the gospel explicitly, then we will not
have honoured our ministry.
Yet, because such a
careful first step is needed, perhaps we are in danger of
underestimating that God is still at work "with thee when we know
it not", as Wordsworth wrote. We are being asked to reveal our
confidence in God: the good news that God is working in people's
lives. What is more, we are being asked to show that people's
relationship with God can be enriched through contact with their
own tradition, which seeks only to look for where grace is working
within them, and to serve.
Many of us have spent
years working with people who have left the Church. Yet the public
seems to be saying that we are a long way from doing enough. This
voice should not be heard with disappointment, because their
renewed interest is a great opportunity to move forward.
Some people look for a
connection with our belief in hospitality and community; others
need to find support in conscience; while others want a loving God,
or God's awe-inspiring mystery; and others still need to find a way
to live with fear and doubt. They look to us to listen to them, and
to accompany them. Our rich tradition, filled with people exploring
God in music, literature, the arts, architecture, nature,
hospitality, social action, community involvement, inner
development, spiritual experience, and so much more, is there to be
used in all its variety.
If we could find the
courage to step into conversation, and not to underestimate the
trust that needs to be rebuilt; if we could have the faith to meet
these people with their doubts; if we could look for grace in their
lives in new ways - then we might find, with the grace of God, that
we are able to serve them again.
The Revd Marie-Elsa
Bragg is Assistant Curate at St Mary's, Kilburn, and St James's,
West Hampstead, and a Duty Chaplain at Westminster Abbey.