Council defends Paganism in RE lessons in schools

19 April 2012

by Margaret Holness Education Correspondent

Local interest: the Mên-an-Tol, or “Crick Stone” standing stones, near Madron, near Penzance SHUTTERSTOCK

Local interest: the Mên-an-Tol, or “Crick Stone” standing stones, near Madron, near Penzance SHUTTERSTOCK

CORNWALL Council confirmed this week that teaching about Paganism has been a religious-education option in the Duchy’s schools since a revision of the locally agreed RE syllabus last year. After claims of “witchcraft lessons” made in a Sunday newspaper last weekend, a spokeswoman said that Paganism was just one option avail­able to schools that were within sight of standing stones, or where some pupils had Pagan parents.

But the RE adviser for Cornwall, David Hampshire, said that the intention was wider. The option was developed after the Agreed Syllabus Conference decided to produce a specifically local element, “Cur­riculum Kernewek” (Cornish cur­ricu­lum), for the county, which has more Neolithic sites than anywhere else in Britain. “This includes in­formation about Cornwall’s many local saints and historic Christian associations, as well as Paganism,” Mr Hampshire said.

A statement from the Council this week, “The Teaching of Paganism in Cornish Schools”, gave details. It says that at Key Stage 1, if there are sites “within the vicinity of the school it would seem right to ex­plore them as part of a pupil’s broader religious education.

“At Key Stage 3 schools have the opportunity to look at the develop­ment of modern Paganism and why it is important for some in Cornwall, and about why pre-Christian sites have gained significance for these diverse groups. . .

“Whilst Paganism will not be a major feature of Cornish RE, given the time to be spent on Christianity (not less than 60% of RE in any one year . . .) and the other major religious traditions (not more than 40% . . .) it will give pupils the opportunity to look at an increasingly significant family of new religious traditions that are important for some people in the Duchy.”

The chairman of Cornwall’s Stand­ing Advisory Council for Religious Education, which monitors the sub­ject locally, the Revd Mike Coles, pastor of Falmouth Evangelical Church, said: “It seems right to de­velop a distinctively Cornish element that included the early Celtic saints, the influence of John Wesley, and the history of Truro Cathedral, as well as the significance of pre-Christian sites.”

Other church leaders in Cornwall have also defended the syllabus. The chairman of Cornwall Methodist District, the Revd Steven Wild, said: “Knowledge is not a threat. This area has preserved much of its ancient culture, and if a school is within sight of some standing stones it is helpful if children understand what they represent.”

A statement from Truro diocese said that the subject of Paganism, and its inclusion in the curriculum, had been misrepresented and taken out of context. “Children should have op­por­tunities to gain understanding in the context of their own locality,” the diocesan director of education, Sue Green, said.

“The syllabus allows teachers to respond to — and celebrate — local diversity, and provide children with the knowledge to develop appropriate attitudes to different religions. It makes it clear that Christianity should predominate at each key stage.”

Last week’s allegations of witch­craft lessons emerged from a national trawl of RE syllabuses undertaken by The Mail on Sunday, under the Freedom of Information Act, it is understood. The director the Culham Institute, a research and develop­ment centre for RE, the Revd Dr John Gay, said: “The syllabus recognises that Cornwall has become a place of spiritual inquiry, drawing in a dis­proportionate following of non- traditional religions. It would be educationally wrong to ignore this aspect of a child’s local experience.

“RE lessons are not about inculcat­ing any one belief, but are set within the educational context of the overall curriculum. No scope, then, for reli­gious heavy-sell, and certainly not for lessons in broomstick-riding.”

Coronavirus (Covid-19) update

The latest: Daily news updates

Get the free Church Times email bulletin


> Lift Up Your Hearts: 3 April (PDF download)

> All our recommended resources for prayer, worship, live streaming and more


Unable to get to the newsagent or pass on your copy of the Church Times as usual?

Get the paper delivered for the next few weeks

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)