ONE of the high points of the annual Three Choirs Festival
(Arts, 3 August) - and Hereford this year was no exception - is the
concert given by the Three Cathedral Choirs: a contrast to the
large main chorus, but also almost invariably a sortie into Baroque
or Classical repertoire that calls for delicate expertise and
stylish, polished delivery.
It was this prodigiously gifted and thoughtful triple choir, and
particularly the boys' singing of the top line, superbly rehearsed
and always intelligently phrased, that rendered Geraint Bowen's
interpretation of Bach's St John Passion such a triumphant
success. Armed with a team of particularly fine soloists, he
elicited from the choir a performance that hit all the right
nerves, tightly structured, full of drama and intensity, rich in
nuance, intensely moving, and, at its best, both profound and
electrifying.
The tenor James Oxley, heard to marvellous effect earlier in the
week in Haydn's Creation and (in a Sunday-morning
liturgical context) Nelson Mass, took over as Evangelist
at short notice. His pliancy, enticing characterisation, and
brilliant range of moods alone guaranteed a performance of note.
Alex Ashworth was a particularly noble Christus; Iestyn Davies was
first tender and then forthright in the later alto arias
(especially heart-rending in the anguished "Es ist
vollbracht", "It is finished"); and the other solos - above
all, from the baritone Matthew Brook, tender and touching, were
sensitive and exquisitely shaped. One could ask no more, but there
was more: the boys' - and not just the leading boys' -
attentiveness and, especially, their splendid understanding and
enunciation of German made this a vivid experience. One need not
have asked for a better, shrewder handling of Bach's
masterpiece.
There were, in a sense, two finales to a packed week. In recent
years, the Three Choirs has rightly placed an emphasis on community
involvement - and with some rather remarkable results. Right at the
end of the week, a collective choir drawn from ten enthusiastic
ensembles across the county, plus a splendid (and very young)
collection of children from local primary schools, served up a
programme, "The Gathering Wave". Some 16 items, some extended, and
couched in six or more languages (none of which seemed to phase
this plucky chorus, whose enunciation - not least the children's -
was dazzlingly good), delighted. The choir had expression and
flair, and a command of rhythm and fine tuning. This was a tight,
attentive ensemble, whose precision seemed all the more impressive
given their different provenances.
Inevitably, the greatest pleasure came from a series of South
African songs, led by a characterful soloist Njabulo Madlala,
including the wonderful "Nkosi Sikelel' iAfrika" ("God
Bless Africa"); but there was much else, of which the most
important was a perky travelogue (a Three Choirs commission) from
Bernard Hughes, which, with its helter-skelter world tour, inspired
by Hereford's medieval Mappa Mundi, picked up the theme of Travel
and the Sea (as did the concert's title), which was central to this
year's festival. The icing on the cake was the gracious and
entertainingly self-mocking compèring by the Dean of Hereford, the
Very Revd Michael Tavinor.
The conclusion of the main festival was positively explosive.
Bowen had begun the jamboree with a beautifully secure and fluent
reading of Haydn's Creation, which set a high benchmark
for the whole week (the soprano Elizabeth Cragg made a special
impact with her pure and unadorned tone as the angel Gabriel and
later Eve - "Ye purling fountains, tune His praise, and wave your
tops, ye pines!").
He now essayed something at the opposite end of the scale. The
Philharmonia was ready to let its hair down, and Bowen programmed a
spectacular performance of Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture
(both an anniversary in itself and a nod to the 2012 Olympics),
which was all the better for being carefully graded, so that the
climaxes gained in impact. The cathedral acoustic worked wonders
with this audial assault, and even more so for what followed: if
one wants a composer to outblast Tchaikovsky, one could not pick
better than Berlioz.
His long-gestated setting of the Te Deum, like his
Requiem and recently discovered Mass, is rich in choral
and orchestral bombast, taking its lead from, among other composers
of the Revolutionary era, his teacher, Le Sueur (whose massive
works maybe merit rediscovery). The organ part, shared between the
(here) flamboyant duo Peter Dyke and Christopher Allsop,
contributed much throughout; the lower voices were in as fine
fettle as the brass section; the chorus Sanctus was truly vivid;
and the final section, "Judex crederis" ("We believe that
thou shalt come to be our judge"), with its descending bell-like
effects, was as thrilling as the rest.
The Philharmonia, who lent such musical excellence to the whole
week, and has now embarked on an official three-year residency with
the Three Choirs Festival, played like eager beavers; and Bowen,
impres-sively relaxed but patently the hero of the week, secured
another feather in his cap.