Giles Fraser: Looking at the fearful, insular US

06 October 2010

THE Tea Party movement in the United States takes some under­stand­ing by us Brits. A right-wing populist movement, the Tea Party originated last year, in protest against President Barack Obama’s economic-stimulus and health-care legislation. The name Tea Party com­bines a reference to the foundation of American identity in the resistance to unfair taxation which was the Boston Tea Party of 1773 with the simple acronym TEA — taxed enough already. Now, 18 per cent of Americans identify themselves as Tea Party supporters.

Most of these are traditional Republicans — but they are as much disaffected with the Republican Party as with the Democrats. Despite all his rhetoric about limiting the place of government, President George W. Bush expanded the power of the state. He may have cut some taxes, but he increased public spend­ing significantly.

President Bush wanted things both ways. But, actually, so does the Tea Party. Although it says it wants to cut government spending, it refuses to specify what it would cut. Would it trim the budget for the military, for instance? Most of its supporters remain inscrutable on the subject. Some say they would actually increase military spending.

The US is a place that has always sold itself the myth of super­abundance — it is the land of bounty from sea to shining sea. In this super-size culture, where more is always better and achievable, the idea that there may be limit and con­straint is hard to stomach. Driving through South Carolina, it is clear that the current economic reality is tough for many ordinary Americans. Many have lost their jobs; house prices remain stagnant; middle-class earn­ings have flatlined. Super­abund­ance no longer rings true.

Alongside this, many are ex­pressing an anxiety that they are losing their place as the world’s top dog. The instinct for economic protectionism against the economic threat of China is growing steadily. It is remarkable how quickly the US is prepared to abandon its apparent commitment to the free market. Others argue that the Tea Party is really a protest by middle-class white men over 45, who feel their position of dominance in US society is slip­ping away. It is all about the existence of a black man in the White House.

At times such as this, the US seems remarkably parochial and insular. The Tea Party sums up all that is most defensive about the American psyche. And it feels like no co­incidence that the US government has now chosen to warn its citizens about travel in Europe and the threat of an attack from al-Qaeda. It’s little wonder that few people here are prepared to cut military spending. Fear breeds fear.

The Revd Dr Giles Fraser is Canon Chancellor of St Paul’s Cathedral.

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read five articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)