Christians are discriminated against in UK, say bishops

30 March 2010

by Ed Beavan

SIX BISHOPS and a former Arch­bishop of Canterbury, Lord Carey, have expressed their concern that the religious rights of Christians in the UK “are being treated with dis­respect”. They spoke out as a Christian nurse, Shirley Chap­lin, took her hospital trust to an em­ployment tribunal, after it had ordered her to remove a crucifix from around her neck in the work­place (News, 25 September).

In a letter to The Sunday Tele­graph, Lord Carey, with the former Bishop of Rochester, Dr Michael Nazir-Ali, and the Bishops of Winchester, Chester, Hereford, Black­burn, and Lichfield, wrote that they were “deeply concerned at the apparent discrimination shown against Christians”. They called on the Government to “remedy this serious development”.

They said that “Christian beliefs on marriage, conscience, and wor­ship were simply not being upheld,” and cited the case of Mrs Chaplin as an example of discrim­ination faced by Christians in the workplace.

During the first day of her employment tribunal on Monday, Mrs Chaplin, who is claiming religious discrimination against the Royal Devon and Exeter NHS Trust, said she had been forced to choose between her faith and her job, when asked to remove her crucifix.

Mrs Chaplin told the tribunal that she believed the headscarves of two Muslim colleagues presented more of a health-and-safety risk than her cross on a chain. She said she had been told that she could pin the cross to the inside of her pocket, which proved that the Trust “simply wanted to remove the visibility of the crucifix”.

The Trust says the issue is about compliance with its uniform policy.

The Bishops’ letter has received a mixed reaction from other church leaders. The Bishop of Lichfield, the Rt Revd Jonathan Gledhill, one of the seven signatories to the letter, explained that he felt motivated to sign it because of a “creeping secularisation” that he perceived.


“The Government seems to be ignoring the Christian conscience and teaching about marriage, and treating us as if we are a minority, when in fact 72 per cent of people say they are Christian.” He called for a debate on the place of Christian faith in public life. The next logical step from the secularists, he argued, would be to remove the cross from the St George’s flag.

Dr Philip Giddings, chairman of the Church of England’s Mission and Public Affairs Council, said he agreed with the content of the Bishops’ letter, and would have liked to have signed it in a personal capacity. There needed to be a “thorough and careful examination” by the Government of the situation for Christians. It was a question of balancing “rights and responsibil-ities in a society of many faiths and none”.

The current situation reflected a “rather impoverished understanding of equality and fairness by members of the Government and their advisers”. Dr Giddings acknowledged that not all members of the Church of England would agree on the level of discrimination against Christians in the UK, but said he believed that there was agreement about a “grow­ing secularisation within Govern­ment as an institution, which threatens to undermine the import­ant position of faith”.

He predicted challenging times ahead for Christians, but said that this would bring “lots of opportun­ities. The Christian community is going to have to face quite a number of vigorous challenges, which in a way will be quite good for us, as there are a number of things we take for granted and need to think through.”

Lord Harries of Pentregarth, the former Bishop of Oxford, was keen to emphasise that he believed other faith groups were “amongst the strongest defenders of the place of Christianity in our culture and morality”. He said that the margin­alisation of Christians was coming from “a few shallow-minded secu­larists who have a thin un­der­standing of our history and culture”.

He called for a sense of per­spective. “There are Christians being oppressed and killed for their faith in some countries of the world.”

The Bishop of Lincoln, Dr John Saxbee, commented: “Christianity is a robust religion, which has survived and even been strengthened by periods of active persecution or even benign neglect.” He described recent instances of Christians’ having been inhibited from wearing symbols of their faith as being “as silly as they are insulting”.

He called on Christians to take every opportunity to “promote marriage and resist all attempts to undermine it”, but warned that this “must never be used as a cover for anti-gay agendas”.


Leader comment

Giles Fraser


Giles Fraser


Are Christians discriminated against in the UK? Vote here

TWO Christian hoteliers, Ben and Sharon Vogelenzang, who were cleared of religiously aggravated and threatening behaviour towards a Muslim guest (News, 11 December) are to sell their hotel because of financial difficulties.

The couple, who run the Bounty House Hotel in Aintree, Liverpool, suffered an 80-per-cent decline in income, after a hospital near by stopped referring clients to them after their trial. They are now considering a civil action against the police who prosecuted them.

THE campaigning group Christian Voice is claiming that Classic FM dropped a competition for listeners to win tickets for a screening of Eric Idle’s “comic oratorio” Not the Messiah, after a cam­paign against the radio station. The group described the show as blasphem­ous. It is based on the Monty Python film The Life of Brian. But a spokes­woman for Classic FM said that the advertising campaign had simply run its course. “This was paid-for advertising approved by the Radio Advertising Clearance Centre, and not editorial content generated by Classic FM.”

A NEW code of conduct drawn up by the General Pharmaceutical Council is continuing to allow pharmacists to opt out of dispens­ing contraceptive pills on the grounds of religion. The Na­tional Secular Society had called for the “conscience clause” to be scrapped.

Forthcoming Events

5 June 2019
Green Health Live 2 | Lambeth Palace
A day conference for chaplains, health care professionals and all those interested in the healing environment.  More details.

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read five articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)