Dioceses receive reassurance from Church Commissioners

05 March 2009

by Ed Beavan

Seven fat cows: the Church Commissioners paid out less to dioceses "in good years, in order to keep something in hand to cover leaner years".

Seven fat cows: the Church Commissioners paid out less to dioceses "in good years, in order to keep something in hand to cover leaner years".

THE Church Commissioners wrote to every diocese last Friday to allay fears over funding levels, after the Church of England suffered an estim­­ated 22 per cent loss.

Andrew Brown, Secretary to the Church Commissioners, confirmed that this loss equated to about £1.2 billion, based on the last valuation of its assets in late 2007, which totalled £5.6 billion. He said that this reduction was not as severe as losses on the FTSE 100 index, which had fallen by an average of 30 per cent.

In a letter to every diocesan board of finance, Mr Brown said that the Church Commissioners would be able to maintain planned levels of support for dioceses until the end of 2010, and might be able to continue until 2011-13.

He said this was possible because the Commissioners had paid out less to dioceses “in good years, in order to keep something in hand to cover leaner years”.

He mentioned that, over the past dec­ade, the total return on the Com­mis­sioners’ investment fund — which includes a portfolio of assets of commercial, residential, and rural property investments, as well as stock market investments — had averaged 5.4 per cent per annum. This figure takes into account unaudited figures for 2008.

It also shows the effect of the finan­cial crisis, as the ten-yearly average return, until the end of 2007, had been 9.5 per cent per annum.

The Church’s return still re­mained significantly better than the profits of 200 similarly sized funds, which had averaged just 3.7 per cent, and meant the Commissioners had been able to distribute about £21 million more each year to the Church over the past decade.

“The impact of the overall finan­cial situation would be much greater”, Mr Brown wrote, had the Commissioners not taken a range of steps before the full extent of the financial crisis was felt by the mar­kets. These included reducing resid­en­tial property holdings, selling commercial properties, and investing in more overseas stock-markets and property.


Speaking to the Church Times on Monday, Mr Brown remained posi­tive about the situation, despite the continuing uncertainty in the finan­cial markets. “It’s good news that we are able to make available the money in capital markets that we said we would. We are no different from any other investor: we have the same pressures as any other investor.”

But, he said, it was impossible to tell whether current levels of funding could be maintained after 2010. A decision would be taken after the figures were released at the end of this year.

Last month, the Church of Eng­land confirmed that it had with­drawn its investment in Caterpillar, the bull­dozer company that manu­factures machines that were used by the Israeli government to destroy Pales­tinian settlements (News, 13 February).

Bishop’s call for giving. The Bishop of Bradford, the Rt Revd David James, has called for people to give their way out of the current eco­nomic crisis. The Christian response to the recession, he said, began with “the Church and her members living out the values of the Kingdom”, and “rediscovering the mutuality which is the foundation of our building societies and our credit unions”.

People who were still working, or whose pensions had been unaffected by the fall in interest rates, should “give more on behalf of those who have less”, she suggested.

Forthcoming Events

21-22 February 2020
Church Times Festival of Faith and Literature
For 2020 the Bloxham festival celebrates ‘The Power of Love’. Tickets available next month. More details

26 March 2020
Theology Slam Live Final
Competition opens in November - more details coming soon. Read about the 2019 final

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read five articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)