*** DEBUG END ***

Primates trivialised problem — Akinola

26 February 2009

by Pat Ashworth

THE Archbishop of Nigeria, the Most Revd Peter Akinola, has dis­missed the Primates’ Meeting in Alex­andria this month as having “trivialised” the situation before it (News, 13 February).

In a letter sent to the Archbishop of Canterbury on 10 February, Arch­bishop Akinola expresses his admira­tion for the gracious way Dr Wil­liams has borne “the divergent views and the enormous pain they im­pose”, before charging both the Epis­copal Church in the United States and the Anglican Church of Canada with taking recent actions “in direct contradiction to the season of deeper communion and greater restraint to which we all expressed agreement”.

He goes on to say that without a “radical change of behaviour” by the two North American Churches, the only outcome of the profession­ally mediated conversation that Dr Williams has initiated will be “ac­knowledgement of a bitter truth that the differences . . . are ‘irrecon­cilable’.”

Archbishop Akinola refers to a report, Tearing the Fabric to Shreds, by the conservative grouping, the American Anglican Council (AAC), which he commissioned and circulated to Primates in preparation for the meeting. He has since made it available more widely “to enable people in the wider Communion to have a fuller perspective of the cir­cum­stances in North America”.

The 42-page document accuses the Episcopal Church in the US of “systematically destroying the founda­tions of Anglican Christianity within the USA” and “tearing the fab­ric of the Anglican Communion to shreds”.

It lists a “Catalogue of Heresies”, in which it charges the Presiding Bishop, Dr Katharine Jefferts Schori, with affirming Pelagianism, Mar­cion­ism, pluralism, universalism, and Gnosticism. Among the evid­ence cited is: “Asked about the literal story of Easter and the Resur­rection, Jefferts Schori said, ‘I think Easter is most profoundly about meaning, not mechanism.’”

Others, such as the Episcopal diocese of Utah, stand accused over state­ments such as: “There is no single biblical morality. Few biblical scholars would claim that a mono­chromatic approach to ethics and human behaviour exists in the Holy Scriptures. . . The Holy Scriptures, written in antiquity, could not and did not foresee many of the ethical questions we have in our age.”

A parallel, though much slimmer, document, also using the title Tearing the Fabric to Shreds, has come from the conservative body the Anglican Network in Canada. Those charged with “Denial of the Authority of Scripture” are the Bishop of New Westminster, the Rt Revd Michael Ingham; the former Primate of the Anglican Church in Canada, the Most Revd Andrew Hut­chison; and two other bishops.

Both the US and Canadian docu­ments list in detail the actions taken against priests and congregations who are dissenting from their Churches. The AAC report includes a history of the lawsuits initiated by the Episcopal Church.

The Primates’ discussions on the desperate situations in Zimbabwe, Sudan, and Gaza prompted Bishop Bob Duncan, Moderator of the Com­mon Cause Partnership, to con­cede, in a response to the Primates’ Meeting, that the immediate tem­poral circumstances of North Am­erica were “in no way as severe as those in other regions”.

Yet the “spiritual consequences of innovations in Faith and Order are staggering”, Bishop Duncan said. He appreciated the “public recognition by the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Windsor continuation group of the desire of the ‘coalition’ (the Common Cause Partnership) consti­tuting the new Anglican Church of North America ‘to be Anglican and to be in relationship with the An­glican Communion.’”

He found “honesty in the written Communiqué” and “a yearning for ‘accountability,’ even ‘robust ac­count­ability’,” but said that the “innovations, punitive lawsuits, and abuses of the Episcopal Church continue to take a toll. They proceed unrepentant and undeterred.”

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)