Paul Vallely: A moral response to terrorism

22 July 2009

How far do just-war principles have to change?

IS IT morally acceptable to shoot Osama bin Laden? Supposing the al-Qaeda leader could not be captured but could be targeted for killing by a commando unit, how would that accord with the principles of just war?

There was an interest­ing discussion on whether “the war on terror” re­quired us to update the moral theology of war on Radio 4’s Sunday programme this week. On one side was Alan Dershowitz, the Harvard Professor of Law who stirred controversy after the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the United States. He had sug­gested that torture was ethically permissible in a “ticking-bomb” scenario where people would die if a suspect did not reveal vital information.

On the other was Nigel Biggar, Regius Profes­sor of Moral and Pastoral Theology at Oxford, who is a canon of Christ Church and who has written in the past on how Christian notions of forgiveness and reconciliation can overcome violence.

You might have expected the two men would disagree, but they did not, at least so far as the discussion was allowed to proceed. Different times and different modes of warfare meant that the notion of just war must be redefined. A theory developed in an era when war was between two uniformed armies needed updating in con­flicts where combatants do not belong to regular armies but blend deliberately into the civilian population and use the innocent as human shields.

Surprisingly perhaps, the theologian agreed that it was OK to kill the al-Qaeda leader because behind the traditional distinction between com­batant and non-combatant lies a desire to limit damage to innocent civilians. On this, Profes­sor Biggar said, “just-war theory is lot more supple than international law.”

I began to feel uneasy, and became more so when Professor Dershowitz talked of a “con­tinuum of civilianality”, which says that terrorist leaders and bombers are the most guilty, but that those who harbour them are guilty, too, if less so; and so the dilution continued down to babies, whose death is always unjust.

This is a superficially attractive notion, but it leads, as in Israel, to justifications such as that it is OK for an army to bomb a house if it has told the occupants to leave, and they decline, for what­ever reason, to do so. Professor Dershowitz adduces what he calls “dead-baby syndrome”, whereby insurgents put women and children in harm’s way in the hope that the enemy will kill them, thus creating a propaganda defeat for the more con­ventionally powerful side.

These are refined arguments from two clever professors, but something in me bridles at the idea of accepting the killing of babies on the grounds that the insurgents who deliberately put the innocents into the firing line bear greater res­ponsibility than the army that fires the shells that kill the children.

Perhaps Professor Biggar would have got there, too, had he been allowed more time. But his in­sistence that “an infringement of law might not be an infringement of the principles of just war” seemed odd. Morality should set the bar higher, not lower, than the law.

“We have to rethink the rules, but it’s impor­tant we don’t throw away the constraints,” the theo­logian conceded. But the conditions set by Aquinas included not only that war must be a response to an injustice and a last resort, but also that it must be conducted with proportionality and the expecta­tion of victory. It is hard to see how we might expect anything other than a Pyr­rhic victory if it involves inflicting propaganda defeats with dead babies upon ourselves.

Democracies are at a tremendous disadvantage when it comes to terrorism, Professor Dershowitz suggests. Yet that is even truer if we throw away the values on which that democracy rests in an ends-justify-the-means determination to win.

Paul Vallely is associate editor of The Independent.

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)