Don’t blame only the bankers — Williams

11 March 2009

by a staff reporter

Don't blame the bankers: the Bank of England PA

Don't blame the bankers: the Bank of England PA

RESPONSIBILITY for the present financial crisis does not rest solely with bankers, the Archbishop of Canterbury said in a lecture in Cardiff on Saturday.

“It is a little too easy to blame the present situation on an accumulation of individual greed, exemplified by bankers or brokers, and to lose sight of the fact that governments committed to deregulation and to the encouragement of speculation and high personal bor­rowing were elected repeatedly in Britain and the United States for a crucial couple of decades. . . We are left with the question of what it was that skewed the judgement of a whole so­ciety, as well as of financial profes­sion­als.”

In his lecture, Dr Williams dis­man­tled capitalism into its constituent parts, finding an element of ethical purpose at its centre in the way it sought to limit risk and share wealth. Present-day capitalism, however, had lost sight of these principles, not least the links between money and labour, and power and powerlessness.

Successive governments colluded with the concept of reducing financial risk for the people and increasing choice: “Government rests its legitimacy upon its capacity to satisfy consumer demands and maximise choices.”

Two essential elements of capitalism — the handling of risk, and the hus­banding of finite resources — had been forgotten in recent years, Dr Williams suggested. Investments in financial services helped to “foster the illusion that the money market is effectively risk-free”.

Dr Williams argued strongly that an ethical economy had necessarily to be a global one. This was highlighted by the harmful consequences of protectionism, “one of the most effective ways to freeze developing economies in a state of perpetual disadvantage. . .

“Morally, protectionism implicitly accepts that wealth maintained at the cost of the neighbour’s disadvantage — or worse — is a tolerable situation, which is a denial of the belief that what is good for humanity is ultimately coherent or convergent.”

Implicit in a global perspective was care for the planet. “There needs to be a robust rebuttal of any idea that environ­mental concerns are somehow a side issue, or even a luxury in a time of eco­nomic pressure.”

Dr Williams concluded by ques­tioning the “unexamined” goal of growth. “Growth out of poverty” was a manifestly good and ethically serious goal. But “a goal of growth simply as an indefinite expansion of purchasing power is either vacuous or malign — malign to the extent that it inevitably implies the diminution of the capacity of others in a world of limited resource.”

Forthcoming Events

5 September 2019
Church Times Cricket Cup Final
Join us at the Walker Cricket Ground in London for the Cricket Cup Final.  More details

8-10 September 2019
The Festival of Preaching
Tickets have now sold out.  Join the waiting list

Job of the Week


Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read five articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)