Shock and anger after Gaza attack

16 November 2006

Reduced to rubble: children play in front of their house, which was damaged during an Israeli attack on Beit Hanoun in the Gaza Strip last week. The attack on civilians was the result of an error, the Israeli army said

Reduced to rubble: children play in front of their house, which was damaged during an Israeli attack on Beit Hanoun in the Gaza Strip last week. The a...

by Gerald Butt
Middle East Correspondent

THE inhabitants of the Gaza Strip remain in shock after the Israeli assault on Beit Hanoun last week, in which 18 Palestinian civilians were killed. The incident has highlighted the political and diplomatic vacuum in the region, and has hardened anti-Israeli and anti-Western sentiments in the Arab world.

The Israeli army says that the attack was an error resulting from a technical failure in a tank’s artillery radar system. But this explanation has not been accepted in the Gaza Strip. According to the Revd Hanna Massad of the Gaza Baptist Church, the assault on Beit Hanoun caused “a vast amount of infrastructure damage. Tanks ploughed through people’s homes to avoid travelling on the streets.”

Bishop Munib Younan, the leader of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Jordan and the Holy Land, said the attack on Beit Hanoun, which caused “extensive destruction of property”, showed “blatant disregard for innocent human life”. European Union Foreign Ministers had earlier denounced the Israeli action as “unacceptable”.

Palestinian and Arab anger increased when the United States vetoed a draft resolution at the United Nations Security Council condemning the Beit Hanoun killings. The US ambassador said the draft was “unbalanced” because it did not condemn Hamas militants for firing rockets into Israel, which provoked the Israeli retaliation.

Against this background of international bickering, there seems little prospect of a diplomatic move to end the violence in Gaza, which, in recent months, has resulted in the deaths of about 300 Palestinians and three Israelis. Several weeks of negotiations between the Palestinian Prime Minister, Mahmoud Abbas, and Hamas leaders have so far failed to produce an agreement on a government of national unity which would be acceptable to the international community. And the Israeli Prime Minister, Ehud Olmert, following his army’s experience in Lebanon, appears to be in no mood to think about peace talks with the Palestinians.

These unpromising diplomatic prospects, combined with chronic economic and social problems, are making life for Palestinians in Gaza increasingly difficult. “As a minister,” Mr Massad said, “I try to encourage the people to have hope. But things are as bleak as ever.”

The Beit Hanoun killings — which have been shown in detail on Arab satellite television — have reinforced Arab hostility towards Israel and the West. In the view of one Saudi commentator, the perceived injustice of the killings and the subsequent US veto “breeds fury in Arab and Muslim hearts, promotes anger in the Arab and Muslim streets, and fuels hatred for those who shield killers from punishment, applaud injustice, and condone the slaughter of innocent civilians.”

Building trust between the Arab world and Israel looks a formidable challenge.


Forthcoming Events

26 March 2020
Theology Slam Live Final
Hear three of the UK’s best up-and-coming young theologians as they reflect on the most pressing issues of our time.  Book tickets

Welcome to the Church Times

​To explore the Church Times website fully, please sign in or subscribe.

Non-subscribers can read four articles for free each month. (You will need to register.)