What is before us, we know not, whether we shall live or die; but
this we know, that all things are ordered and sure. Everything is ordered with
unerring wisdom and unbounded love, by thee, O God, who art love. Grant us in
all things to see thy hand; through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Charles Simeon (1759-1836)
AT FIRST glance, Charles Simeon's prayer seems enormously reassuring. In a
world that is often bewildering, haphazard, and cruel, Simeon asserts that the
hand of God is to be found "in all things". The apparent chaos of the world is
misleading. In its place, according to Simeon's prayer, a more discerning eye
would see design and purpose.
Faith in divine control provides many with comfort, particularly when bound
up with the belief that the chaos is not only ordered and sure, but ordered
with "unerring wisdom and unbounded love". The intent of the prayer is one that
we often pray. We yield ourselves to God's will, and submit ourselves to
whatever happens to us, in the belief that it is all part of God's plan for us.
In faith, we hope, it will be all right in the end.
The temptation of Simeon's prayer, however, is to fall into a kind of
passivism that accepts that everything is the best it can be because God
controls it all; therefore, it is exactly as he wills it (who then are we to
try to alter or challenge it?). Or the temptation is to fall into cynicism or
despair if the evidence of God's love in all things that come our way, or in
the horrors that we see around us, runs thin. It would be hard to claim that
the evidence points to the world's being ordered entirely with wisdom.
In place of passivism, the Church proclaims its belief in life before death,
and in the importance of our help - now - in changing things. Poverty and war
are not to be easily accepted as part of a divinely ordered world, let alone as
aspects of wisdom and love, but as blemishes on creation, and an insult as much
to God as to us. We are called to be partners with God, and participants in
bringing about a world that is truly ordered and bound by wisdom and love.
If we were to believe that all things were God's will rather than that God
was present in all things, then, deprived of any true self-governance, we might
fail to walk hand in hand with God in building his Kingdom. We would be tempted
merely to sit back or to obey God's orders like automatons.
Of course, there is greater ambiguity in believing that God is present in
all things than in believing that God wills all things. For those who believe
that God wills all things, reality is the reverse imprint of God's will, and
therefore "self-evident". Presence from which we might draw the same conclusion
is harder to pinpoint.
Divine presence, though, allows greater scope for exercising our free will.
With free will come responsibility and our part, however minor, in our own
sanctification. It is the knowledge that our actions do count, and that it is
not God on his own, but God with us and through us (by God's own choice), which
brings hope, and wards off passivism. Nothing prevents God from exercising his
will, but nothing prevents us from exercising ours, to the extent that we can.
With God's help, we can change the world.
There is undoubted poetry in Simeon's prayer, which forms a condensed credo
of his Evangelical belief. Slain by God's power and love, he portrays in his
prayer a world in which he is convinced that God's power is absolute.
Yet nothing is ever that simple. The Trinity itself stands testament against
anything that claims to be a simple Christian faith. It seems that God holds
back; that the exercise of power is conditional on the consent of our hearts
and minds.
It seems that we are yet far off from a world in which everything is ordered
with unerring wisdom and unbounded love. But we are in a world where God stands
ready to enter our hearts and minds, and to use our hands and talents to bring
about his Kingdom.
The Revd Mark Speeks is Assistant Priest at St James's, West Hampstead,
and St Mary's, Kilburn, London.