New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Book reviews >

Here’s the smell of the blood

Jane Stemp finds this study meticulous, but a little limited

Medieval Blood
Bettina Bildhauer
University of Wales Press £55
(0-7083-1940-8)
Church Times Bookshop £49.50

AS the dust-jacket claims, this is indeed “a sustained study of one of the crucial elements of medieval imaginations of the world: blood”.

It would have been helpful if the title had been “blood and gender”, and had stressed the aspect of “imagination”; for blood and how it distinguishes the genders is dealt with solely as it appears in literary descriptions and scientific theory in medieval Germany, with a look back at some classical sources.

There is little discussion about how real people in the medieval world reacted to epics, medical theory, or menstruation; and there is no mention, for example, of the pilgrimage site of the Holy Blood of Hailes, nor the miraculous blood of San Gennaro in Naples. Owing to the careful selection of texts, even their authors seem to be building theories rather than setting out to inform or entertain.

This, however, is in the nature of a book of critical theory rather than of general information, and perhaps one should not complain. Bettina Bildhauer has been meticulous in her research, and does not denigrate, as is only too usual, the nature of medieval theories. “I believe that both medieval and modern periods negotiate different levels of scientific and religious knowledge, and that a difference between medieval lack and modern wealth of knowledge cannot be upheld,” she says.

It is fascinating to have glimpses of the German medieval texts less well known to British readers in this area of study. It is to be regretted, perhaps, that while she uses Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice with reference to its pound of flesh, she has not similarly pointed her discussions with references to other familiar texts. Referring to the belief that the corpse of a murder victim bleeds once more in the presence of the murderer, she cites the Nibelungenlied (c.1200), but not the similar folk belief attached to the death of William Rufus in 1087.

Her theory that adding armour, especially dragon’s-blood protection (as with Siegfried), actually pro-voked fiercer attacks and thus greater vulnerability, neglects the moral dimension visible in the earlier Beowulf, where the hero is more successful the less weaponry and armour he uses, or, as is strongly implied, the more he trusts in God’s help.

The book is well produced, and the illustrations interesting if rather grey. This could not, though, be called a book for the general reader, coming as it does from the world of critical theory, where “abject” and “gender” have both become verbs: indeed, its price, too, puts it firmly in the academic bracket. None the less, for the student and the interested researcher it is a detailed and hardworking text in an area that deserves further study.

To order this book email ctbookshop

Job of the week

Anglican Chaplain

North West

EVERYONE DESERVES THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A FRESH STARTWITH YOUR HELP THEY CAN ANGLICAN CHAPLAIN HMP Altcourse, Liverpool £29,000 - £30,700 per annum Full time (35 hours per week) HMP Altcou...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

Suppression, secrecy, and survival: the Hidden Christians of Japan

Suppression, secrecy, and survival: the Hidden Christians of Japan

A new book explores Christianity in Japan. Its author, John Dougill, talks to Malcolm Doney  Subscribe to read more

Top comment

One Church’s mission, but many opportunities

The Renewal and Reform programme needs a wide range of approaches to be successful, argues Andrew Lightbown  Subscribe to read more

Tue 27 Sep 16 @ 10:01
RT @greenbeltThe Top Ten Sellers in @ChurchTimes bookshop at #gb16 are here with 20% off before the end of Sept https://t.co/Qc2RbPF0Xi

Tue 27 Sep 16 @ 9:23
UPDATED: US and Russia exchange barbs as Syrian children die in Aleppo onslaught https://t.co/M6mAd0gnJs