New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Columnists >

O’Brien and the canker of secrecy

Paul Vallely

by Paul Vallely

Posted: 08 Mar 2013 @ 12:03

The RC Church needs to address its culture of priestly pretence, says Paul Vallely

FOR a moment, I felt sorry for Keith Patrick O'Brien. Here was a classic tragedy: a big man brought low by a single fault. After a life of ambitious service, he had been undone by one character flaw, and his fall from grace had been dramatic and swift.

But what, in that classic Shakespearean formula, was Cardinal O'Brien's flaw? Was it, from his own perspective, his homosexual inclinations, or his weakness in acting on them? Or was it, as his critics suggested, the spectacular hypocrisy of a man who was so vitriolic in his public denunciations of homosexuality?

Neither of these responses can be correct. The crime of the former Archbishop of St Andrews & Edinburgh cannot have been being gay; for, except to those who impose moral intent upon nature, being gay is not a sin. But there is a whole gradation of states between a sexual tendency and the rank hypocrisy of a cleric who proclaims a moral blueprint for how people should conduct their lives, and then does not adhere to it himself.

Between homosexuality and hypocrisy lie cognitive dissonance, psychological denial, self-delusion, moral superiority, abuse of authority, institutional secrecy, wilful cover-up, unrighteous indignation, and plain lying. Research from the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in the United States recently offered evidence for what many have long suspected: that many of those most vituperative in speaking out against gays have unconscious or repressed tendencies to homosexual attraction themselves.

Freud called this "reaction formation" - individuals inwardly struggling to stifle feelings that they regard as unacceptable, who then project their inward terror out on others. Suppressed homosexual urges then turn to homophobia, in a form of projected self-loathing. It may explain the virulence of the bluster and bombast of Cardinal O'Brien's public hostility to homosexuality as "morally disordered" and a "grotesque subversion". But it means that Cardinal O'Brien is also a victim, and that, as one commentator put it, the sense of sexual sinfulness that the Church has forced on him was itself an abuse.

There is more to this than being trapped in a cycle of abuse. There is an inequality of power between a spiritual director and a seminarian, or between a bishop and a priest, which adds a different abusive element to the reports that the Cardinal attempted to touch, kiss, or have sex with people in his charge.

There was also a fundamental dishonesty about his initial reaction to the accusations, announcing that he would fight them, and threatening The Observer with legal action. "Initially, their anonymous and non-specific nature led me to contest them," he said in his most recent confession. But he knew well what he had done. And the complainants were not anonymous; they had sent sworn statements to the Papal Nuncio.

The interview given by one of the accusers laid bare the extent to which he had been deeply damaged by what had happened; he resigned from the priesthood when Fr O'Brien was made his bishop, and has undergone long-term psychological counselling. Cardinal O'Brien, by contrast, hoped until the last minute that he could bluff it out, as he has done for decades. It was the response of a trapped man, and not an honourable one.

The Vatican will hold an inquiry into the O'Brien affair, but it will focus on the weakness of one individual. What it needs to address is what trapped Keith O'Brien - a culture of pretence in the priesthood, and a canker of secrecy at the heart of a Church that has systematically placed protecting its institutional reputation above the imperatives of the gospel.

Job of the week

Senior Education and Academies Executive Officer

East Midlands

Diocese of leicester The Diocesan Board of Education St Martins House Peacock Lane Leicester LE1 5PZ The Leicester Diocesan Board of Education Is looklng to appoint two new senior members ...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

Where sacred art comes built in

Where sacred art comes built in

When Jonathan Evens set off on a quest to discover 20th-and 21st-century religious art, he found some hidden gems  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Are foodbanks an effective way of dealing with poverty?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

South Sudan: telling it how it is

It's time to launch a pre-emptive strike against further tragedy, writes Rowan Williams  Subscribe to read more

Fri 28 Nov 14 @ 12:51
Our interview from 2009 with PD James, who died yesterday http://t.co/2v7CmTwt6C http://t.co/NFJ6oISDBf

Fri 28 Nov 14 @ 12:14
Our editor has disloyally written for the Guardian's comment page today. However, it is pretty good. On Black Friday: http://t.co/tHWHa4X9y0