New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
News > UK >

British Airways wrong in cross case, says European Court in landmark judgment

by Gavin Drake

Posted: 15 Jan 2013 @ 12:38


Click to enlarge
Credit: PA

BRITISH courts did not strike a "fair balance" between competing rights when they ruled that British Airways had the right to ban staff from wearing crosses, European judges ruled on Tuesday.

The European Court of Human Rights ruled that the desire of Nadia Eweida (right), an official of the airline's check-in desk, to wear a visible cross was a "manifestation of her religious belief" and, as such, was a "fundamental right" protected by Article Nine of the European Convention of Human Rights.

"On one side of the scales was Ms Eweida's desire to manifest her religious belief," five of the seven judges said in a majority judgment. "On the other side of the scales was the employer's wish to project a certain corporate image. The court considers that, while this aim was undoubtedly legitimate, the domestic courts accorded it too much weight.

"Where there is no evidence of any real encroachment on the interests of others, the domestic courts failed sufficiently to protect [Ms Eweida's] right to manifest her religion."

The Court awarded her damages of €2000 (£1660) with €30,000 (£25,000) costs.

The Court had been asked to adjudicate on four cases of religious discrimination rejected by British courts. The Court took a different view in the case of a nurse, Shirley Chaplin. The prohibition on wearing a cross as a necklace was imposed on her by the Royal Devon and Exeter NHS Foundation Trust "to reduce the risk of injury when handling patients".

The Court said: "The reason for asking her to remove the cross, namely the protection of health and safety on a hospital ward, was inherently of a greater magnitude than that which applied in respect of Ms Eweida."

The judges said that "hospital managers were better placed to make decisions about clinical safety than a court."

In two other linked cases, the court ruled against former Islington registrar Lillian Ladele, dismissed for refusing to conduct civil partnerships; and Relate counsellor Gary McFarlane, dismissed over concerns about his attitude towards the provision of psycho-sexual therapy to same-sex couples.

In both cases, the judges said that Islington Borough Council and Relate's policies were pursuing a "legitimate aim" of preventing discrimination towards same-sex couples. As a result, there was a "wide margin of appreciation" open to the domestic authorities when weighing the competing rights, which the European judges ruled had not been exceeded.

Reaction to the judgment was swift. Prime Minister David Cameron tweeted: "Delighted that principle of wearing religious symbols at work has been upheld - ppl shouldn't suffer discrimination due to religious beliefs."

The Archbishop of York, Dr Sentamu, welcomed the judgment, saying: "Christians are not obliged to wear a cross but should be free to show their love for and trust in Jesus Christ in this way if they so wish.

"The Equality Act encourages employers to embrace diversity - including people of faith. Whether people can wear a cross or pray with someone should not be something about which courts and tribunals have to rule."

Dr Dave Landrum, director of advocacy for the Evangelical Alliance, warned that the judgment "has shown a hierarchy of rights now exists in UK law". He remarked: "We hope that, in the light of today's decision, employers, public bodies, and courts will seek to understand religious belief better, and build relationships with faith groups to help achieve this. The alternative of a society that is in perpetual legal conflict with itself is both undesirable and unsustainable."

A fuller report will appear in Friday's edition of the Church Times.


Job of the week

Chief Administrator

South East

CHICHESTER CATHEDRAL CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR The Chapter of Chichester seek applicants for the office of Chief Executive Officer, known as COMMUNAR The Communar is responsible for strategic financ...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

A bountiful harvest grown in faith

A bountiful harvest grown in faith

In this extract from their new book, Susie Weldon and Sue Campbell tell the story of Christians and Muslims in Africa who are finding new ways to farm, based on their scriptures  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should the UK take in more refugees fleeing Islamic State's terrorists?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Corporate tax avoider? Shame on you, then!

It might be legal, but is it moral? Geoff Daintree on a new report that challenges people who pay as little tax as they can  Subscribe to read more

Sat 25 Oct 14 @ 10:55
'Moribund churches get the HTB treatment'

Sat 25 Oct 14 @ 9:35
@alansc Hi Alan, We've done this for years. People wanted advance col for time to work on sermons. Col for 26/10 Readings is just below. HS