New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Comment > Letters to the editor >

The Lambeth Commission’s report: how it will play

From Mr Geoff Sage
Sir, — I refer to your report on the work of the Lambeth Commission ( News, 17 September). The comments from the Church of England Evangelical Council (CEEC) and Anglican Mainstream do give cause for concern as we await this important document. Their rush to judgement betrays an arrogance that undermines the serious and difficult work that the Commission has undertaken. Is this their strategy?

I find the comment from the Ven. Paul Gardiner most perplexing. Your reporter quotes him: "We [the CEEC] want to see the Eames report upholding traditional biblical and orthodox understandings of behaviour and the place of holiness in Christian life. We will judge all things by scripture."

It is interesting to hear of an Evangelical who wants to uphold the traditional and the orthodox. Thank goodness his predecessors didn’t heed this in the 18th century, when they led the fight against slavery. The CEEC appoints itself as the judge of scripture. By what right does it take on this role?

Anglican Mainstream also sees itself as the champion of the orthodox. If we are all trying, however inadequately, to be followers of Jesus Christ, where precisely in the Gospels and in his teachings do they find the exhortation to seek the traditional and the orthodox?

Perhaps they read a different version from mine, with all the unsettling and challenging parts safely bowdlerised.

GEOFF SAGE
Greystones
Easter Moffat
Plains, Airdrie
North Lanarkshire ML6 8NP

From Mr Michael Hampson
Sir, — I am delighted to read that many people will accept the Lambeth report "only if it passes the test of scripture".

I propose three scriptural tests that it must pass if it is to be deemed properly Christian. Matthew 7.1 requires that the report should not involve anybody’s presuming to sit in judgement on anybody else. Hebrews 8.13 and Romans 7.6 require that there should be no dependence whatsoever on Old Testament law. Matthew 22.37-39 requires that the report should be characterised exclusively by compassion.

It is time, as Bishop Gene Robinson has said, to reclaim the Bible from its misrepresentation by those who have taken it hostage and claimed for themselves the exclusive right to speak on its behalf.

MICHAEL HAMPSON
26 Hanover Avenue
London E16 1SD

From Dr Alan Sheard
Sir, — Mr Richard Wilkins ( Letters, 17 September) regards the Pentateuch as "opposed to extramarital affairs". He seems to be unaware of Genesis 16, which says, with apparent approval, that Abraham had a child by his wife’s maidservant Hagar; and chapter 28, which records that Esau chose for a wife Mahalath, daughter of Ishmael, "in addition to the wives he had".

I am not condoning extramarital affairs or polygamy, but merely pointing out that Mr Wilkins’s letter is an example of the casual sophistry and misuse of the Bible which are all that the critics of lesbian and gay people have to offer.

ALAN SHEARD
7 Northfield
Swanland
North Ferriby
East Yorkshire HU14 3RG

 

Job of the week

Inter Religious Affairs Programme Officer

London and Home Counties

Inter Religious Affairs Programme Officer Location: Lambeth Palace, London Salary: Starting salary of £27,911 rising to £30,326 upon successful completion of probation period. Contract Type: Full...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

A poet who sets puzzles

A poet who sets puzzles

After the publication of a new edition of Rowan Williams's poems, Cole Moreton asks the priest-poet what goes on behind the verse  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Is Bishop Inwood right to withhold Canon Pemberton's licence?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Comedian tells Christians how it is

The Church urgently needs a grown-up debate about theology, says Eva McIntyre  Subscribe to read more

Tue 22 Jul 14 @ 9:59
RT @JustinWelbyPraying for the well-being of girls and progress at @GirlSummit #girlsummit, campaign against FGM and child/forced marriage very important

Tue 22 Jul 14 @ 9:59
RT @David_CameronI'll make reporting FGM mandatory for doctors, teachers and social workers. Let's end this abhorrent practice once and for all. #GirlSummit