New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
News >

C of E schools ‘add value’, tables show

TWO Church of England comprehensives, the Bennett Memorial Diocesan School, Tunbridge Wells, and the Bluecoat School, Liverpool, were listed alongside some of the country’s most successful grammars in the top 50 schools according to new “value-added” league tables.

Bennett Memorial also appears with Archbishop Holgate School, York, St Hilda’s, Liverpool, and King’s School, Peterborough, in the list of the top 20 comprehensives at which 14-year-olds scored higher than their performance at the age of 11 might have indicated.

The “value-added” tables combine three measures: results in Key Stage 3 tests at 14 are compared with the same pupils’ attainment aged 11; these are then adjusted for the “innate ability” of pupils, and for the number of pupils receiving free school meals (seen as a guide to an area’s socio-economic conditions). Schools are also divided into benchmark categories, which take into account only the entrance scores of pupils.

Though the value-added tables were meant to be fair to schools in difficult areas, the system has been criticised as flawed by the Office for Standards in Education (OFSTED) as being unfair to many successful comprehensives that have high overall scores. High performing comprehensives, such as St Aidan’s, Harrogate, have to compete with grammars in the top benchmark group, even though it has 35 pupils with statements of special need, including two with Down syndrome, whose test marks are included in the results.

Moreover, even taking value- added measures into account, the tables draw attention to schools with exceptionally low scores. When the tables were published before Christmas, some reports drew attention to the poor performance of St Alban’s, Birmingham, failing to mention that the school has been commended by OFSTED inspectors for its efforts in exceptionally challenging circumstances. Only a minority of pupils speaks English as a first language; and for many it is the first school they have attended.
Job of the week

Chaplain

Wales

EVERYONE DESERVES THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A FRESH START WITH YOUR HELP THEY CAN Chaplain - Ecumenical (HMP Parc) HM Prison & YOI Parc, Bridgend £30,369.42 pa | Full-time (40 hours per w...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

‘I hope that I will be proud of the next thing I write’

‘I hope that I will be proud of the next thing I write’

Jo Wroe talks to the writer and stand-up comic A. L. Kennedy, who will be making her Greenbelt debut this weekend  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should the full synodical process for church legislation be retained?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Exposed — the dangers of a group mentality

One year on, the Rotherham child sexual exploitation scandal reveals the risks of group norms, says Alan Billings  Read More

Fri 28 Aug 15 @ 22:23
“When claimants are allowed to speak for themselves the stories...are very different” http://t.co/bcg6D2hTwj http://t.co/lPu0XrvcG1

Fri 28 Aug 15 @ 21:19
Is it true that marriage is “alive and well” among the rich, but not the poor? http://t.co/bSRzYrzzoi http://t.co/zUDtgTNf0d