New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Comment >

Suffering at the hands of the US

IN THEIR REPORT on counter-terrorism, the Bishops' working party devotes a large section to the religious motivation of the American public. From a 2001 survey by the University of Michigan, the Bishops suggest that almost one quarter (23.1 per cent) of the US population can be described as white, Evangelical Protestants, and that these, combined with conservative elements in the Roman Catholic and mainstream Protestant denominations, make up a majority who think of their nation in religious terms. This view would not surprise the Founding Fathers. It becomes a problem only when Americans attempt to export their vision of themselves. The "war against terror" and the campaigns in Afghanistan and the Middle East, the Bishops say, are just two manifestations of the US's "mission to press for global reform through the spread of traditional American values". They warn: "There is no uniquely righteous nation. No country should see itself as the redeemer nation, singled out by God as part of his providential plan."

The relationship of religious conviction to nationalism is a potent element in Middle Eastern politics. The West regards it as unhelpful when the religion is Islam, as in Iran. When the religion is Christianity, however, its power to enhance nationalist feeling tends to be overlooked. The growth of the British Empire provides ample evidence of the way evangelistic zeal, coupled with commercial advantage, propagated an imperial ambition (though there is evidence, too, that missionaries tempered the more brutal aspects of European expansion). Our history teaches us that we ought to be wary when singling out the US for criticism.

There is, though, something especially worrying about elements within the US administration. The testimony of Clive Stafford Smith, a British lawyer who represents 40 prisoners in Guantánamo, suggests that acting on poor intelligence did not stop with the weapons of mass destruction fiasco. Mr Stafford Smith ( interviewed) says that US investigators did not even have the right name for one of his Guantánamo clients, a 14-year-old boy accused of financing terrorism. One of the reasons for the present hunger strike is that prisoners are being held even after what passes for a fair tribunal has found no evidence against them. There has been no question of compensation for those wrongfully held, even when they bear the evidence of torture.

The US's holding of implausible (and unknown) numbers of terrorist suspects around the world, and the behaviour of some American and British troops in Iraq point up the importance of one of the Bishops' guiding principles, that respect for "basic human dignity . . . ought to be the underlying moral principle for relationships between states, as well as individuals". It is a fitting task for the Churches to monitor the condition of civil liberties around the world. For an adminstration supposedly guided by Christian principles, were are left wondering at how careless the US can be of its prisoners.

Job of the week

Priest in Charge

Wales

Esgobeath Bangor The Diocese of Bangor Eglwys sy'n Dysgu A Learning Church The Bishop of Bangor wishes to appoint a Priest in Charge of Conwy & Gyffin and Ministry Area Leader Designate Th...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

Counting the cost

Counting the cost

Huw Spanner hears tips for people who are interested in banking, investing, and saving more ethically, but who are unsure where to start  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should the UK take in more refugees fleeing Islamic State's terrorists?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Looking for new funds? Pass the ice-bucket

As charities seek to attract a new generation of donors, they are having to find more targeted methods, reports Nick Jowett  Subscribe to read more

Wed 22 Oct 14 @ 12:05
The Archbishop of York says he is "deeply ashamed" by failure of CofE to protect children https://t.co/4WdTZW1JV3

Wed 22 Oct 14 @ 12:04
An inquiry into allegations of sexual abuse by a former Dean of Manchester has identified "systemic failings" in CofE http://t.co/VuuJ5MG75s