New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
News >

Trouble over a crucifix

*

July 14th, 1905.

THE Richmond Town Council seems to have constituted itself a kind of ecclesiastical court, which bases its judgments on the discredited dicta of the late Lord Penzance. It appears that the vicar and churchwardens of St John's Church lately applied to the Town Council for permission to extend the building, and that the scheme included a large crucifix with supporting figures of Our Lady and St John, which it is intended to place on the east wall. To this the Town Council took exception, and bombarded the Bishop of Southwark with extracts from Lord Penzance's judgment in "Ridsdale v. Clifton", in which that learned authority held that a crucifix was illegal, as being "likely to be abused for purposes of superstition". The Bishop, however, refused to be scared by the bogey of Lord Penzance's Court, and pointed out that the churchwardens were entitled to the free use of their discretion. At the last meeting of the Council, one of the Aldermen made the singular proposal that the Bishop should be requested not to sanction the side-figures, though we are glad to see that several Dissenters were in the minority. A little reflection would have shown the worthy Alderman that the addition of the figures converts the whole work into a group of statuary representing a historic scene, and, if there is any possibility of "superstition", it would certainly be minimised by this treatment. Our respect for the intelligence of the Richmond Town Council is not increased by this particular instance of its sagacity.

Job of the week

University Chaplain

South West

University of St Mark & St John, Plymouth Plymouth, Britain's Ocean City University Chaplain With its 175 year heritage, outstanding reputation for teaching in distinctive subject areas a...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

A lantern unto their feet

A lantern unto their feet

The words and, sometimes, the very presence of the Bible were a source of comfort and inspiration during the First World War  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Is outing counter-productive?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Why the worry about ministering together?

Some clergy are too fearful of collaborative ways of working, says Brian Cranwell   Subscribe to read more

Fri 1 Aug 14 @ 17:20
Glasgow's churches are getting in the Commonwealth Games spirit http://t.co/eInGQcGyrO @morethangolduk

Fri 1 Aug 14 @ 15:30
http://t.co/RuxGJqihxU