New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
News >

Farewell to penny plain

The Arts of the Anglican Counter-Reformation: Glory, Laud and honour
Graham Parry

Boydell Press £45 (1-84383-208-9)
Church Times Bookshop £40.50

Alison Shell on a move back to decoration in Laud’s Church

IS IT legitimate to appropriate a Roman Catholic term, “Counter-Reformation”, when referring to the early-17th-century Church of England? And can one even talk of Anglicanism when referring to this period, given that the term was not an established one till later in the century? As ever with terminological issues, answers can vary enormously, and tempers can run high.

But everyone can agree that the Church of England, from roughly the late 1620s to the outbreak of the Civil War, experienced a change of mood that was strongly associated with William Laud, Charles I’s Archbishop of Canterbury.

Theologically, many writers and preachers moved away from em-phasising predestination to re-affirming the place of man’s free will in the process of salvation; and there arose a greater confidence in eccle-siastical authority, attributing higher value to the sacraments than had been characteristic of Elizabethan and early Jacobean Protestantism.

As so often, theological changes led to liturgical and architectural ones. Incense was reintroduced into church services by the Laudians, and under their authority decoration began to creep back into the plain Protestant interior. Cherubs, used in Solomon’s temple and thus unimpeachably biblical, became a particularly popular ornament.

The chapters on the architectural legacy of Laudianism are the most original in Parry’s book, vibrant with enthusiasm and containing an inspiring call to further fieldwork. This is all the more necessary be-cause one of the most moving and evocative of Laudian interiors, undertaken under the inspiration of John Cosin, survived until recent times in the parish church of Brancepeth, Co. Durham, but was destroyed by fire in 1998 — a loss that was surprisingly little lamented in the national press at the time, perhaps because it happened in the North-East.

The same would not have been true for the Oxbridge college chapels, which remain as an equally important reminder of Laudian ideals. Peterhouse chapel in Cam-bridge was immortalised in verse by Richard Crashaw, who subsequently became the curate of Little St Mary’s next door — another interior beautified by Cosin. There, to quote his biographer, Crashaw “lodged under Tertullian’s roofe of Angels”.

As someone who went over to Rome in the mid-1640s after a long period of confessional ambiguity, Crashaw might certainly by his life be seen as testifying to an Anglican Counter-Reformation. With other poets, such as George Herbert, the term seems less applicable, despite Herbert’s well-documented concern for decency and order in church. In such poems as “The Church-Floor”, he allegorises the fashion for diapered tiles: “Mark you the floor? that square and speckled stone Which looks so firm and strong, Is Patience: And th’other black and grave, wherewith each one Is checker’d all along, Humilitie.”

Jacobean and Caroline high-churchmanship has never wanted lay admirers, and academic interest in the period has burgeoned over the past few decades. So this is a splendid topic for an overview; and Parry has given us a well-illustrated, accessible, and elegantly cadenced treatment of what must have been a lavish multi-media experience. The subtitle to the book, “Glory, Laud and honour”, could equally well have been “O worship the Lord in the beauty of holiness”.

Dr Shell is a reader in the department of English at Durham University.

To place an order for this book, email details to CT Bookshop

Job of the week

Team Rector

North West

The Loughrigg Team Partnership Team Rector for the parishes of Ambleside, Brathay and Langdale The Loughrigg Team is situated in and around the small town of Ambleside in the South Lakes area of ...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

It depends what you mean by ‘gaps’

It depends what you mean by ‘gaps’

John Polkinghorne, physicist, priest, and writer, will be 85 on 16 October. Patrick Miles talked to him  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Does the funeral profession need tighter regulation?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

In forgetfulness of the Kingdom

The Church has cut Jesus’s teaching from the heart of its worship, says Hugh Rayment-Pickard  Subscribe to read more

Tue 13 Oct 15 @ 19:40
Reformation under the Victorians | John Goodall surveys dramatic 19th-century changes

Tue 13 Oct 15 @ 17:37
Is the Church stuck with the same old ideas for growth as it had in the 19th century?