New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Reviews > Book reviews >

Stirring discord

Jeremy Craddock on scientists at variance

Click to enlarge


All That Is: A naturalistic faith for the twenty-first century
Arthur Peacocke (Philip Clayton, editor)

Fortress Press £12.99 (978-0-8006-6227-1)
Church Times Bookshop £11.70

THIS IS Arthur Peacocke’s last book, written when he knew he was dying. In a 50-page essay, he seeks to distil his thinking over many years; then come ten responses, of about ten pages each, by other theologians. These are followed by a chapter by Peacocke, in which he assesses their views. (It would be convenient if each of his comments followed the relevant author: one has to flip backwards and forwards.) The whole is preceded by an analysis of it all by the editor.

So I find myself writing a review of the editor’s review of the author’s review of ten reviews of his essay.

I hope I understand correctly: Peacocke invites us to see the universe as naturalistic (events have natural, not supernatural, causes); as emergent (the whole is greater than the sum of its parts); and as panentheistic (the universe is contained within God, who sustains it moment by moment, and therefore interacts constantly with every part of it, but is himself greater than the universe).

My first reaction was disappointment that the list of commentators excluded some who were at odds with him. Neil Messer once wrote that he disagreed with Peacocke “most sharply”; John Polkinghorne has written helpfully about emergence, but rejects panentheism. I need not have worried. Most of the commentators disagree when they feel they should, and make no bones about it. That is particularly so with Keith Ward, and Peacocke’s difficulty in replying. The ten even disagree with each other.

Scientific reductionists might conclude that, if theologians cannot agree, then theology is nonsense. But scientists have not always agreed, and don’t agree now about, say, quantum theory, or even Darwinism. They should read Peacocke’s Nunc Dimittis: “Death comes to everyone, and this is my time.” Humility helps.

The Revd Jeremy Craddock was a forensic biologist.

To order this book, email the details to Church Times Bookshop

Job of the week

Principal

West Midlands

PRINCIPAL ST ALBAN'S ACADEMY Lead an outstanding high-profile school in Birmingham St Alban's Academy serves the Highgate area of Birmingham. It is part of the ARK Schools group, a network of ...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

It’s not all religion’s fault

It’s not all religion’s fault

In her new book, Karen Armstrong argues that violence comes from a deep-seated 'warrior ethos' rather than from religion. She talks to Cole Moreton  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should the seal of the confessional be absolute?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Clergy are ‘more like Old Labour than New’

A survey commissioned to support debates on the future of the C of E yields some interesting results, says Linda Woodhead  Read More

Fri 31 Oct 14 @ 15:11
Canon Alan Billings, Labour Party candidate, elected Police and Crime Commissioner for South Yorkshire. http://t.co/iydy5Z0tDj

Fri 31 Oct 14 @ 14:53
'Positive action' is being taken to create a pool of women ready to be considered for the episcopate http://t.co/mDg7mlOLfo