New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Reviews > Book reviews >

Foiled by anti-clerical politicians

These attempts at reform were worthy, but, alas, doomed, says Alec Ryrie

Click to enlarge

Religion, Reform and Modernity in the Eighteenth Century: Thomas Secker and the Church of England
Robert G. Ingram
Boydell & Brewer £45 (978-1-84383-348-2)
Church Times Bookshop £40.50

IF WE THINK of the 18th-century Church of England at all, we don’t think much of it: a venal, self-satisfied husk of a Church, trapped in formalism. In our minds, the age’s intellectual energies were rationalist and liberal, and its spiritual zeal Nonconformist or Methodist.

Robert Ingram is impatient with these prejudices and the hindsight that forms them. In this invaluable book, he argues that the Established Church was alive and kicking; and he uses Thomas Secker, Archbishop of Canterbury 1758-68, to prove it.

The Secker whose life Ingram traces (though this is more than a biography) mixed moderation and firmness in a manner typical of the age: that is, he was a Whig to his fingertips, for good or for ill. Raised a Dissenter, he converted to Anglicanism in his twenties. The circumstances are opaque, but dislike for Nonconformist Trinitarian specu-lation seems to have been a key. Ingram suggests that Secker’s medical studies were important here, as current theories of life seemed to support a traditional doctrine of the bodily resurrection.

As an Anglican convert, Secker’s rapid rise (he was a bishop at 42) was a matter of luck, political skill, and robust defence of his new faith. His contemporaries found him a powerful preacher. Walpole thought him a touch fanatical; but Ingram prefers his self-description — “orthodox”: willing to reform the old ways, the better to defend them.

Secker was wary of Methodism (like any bishop), but recognised its value. His real enemies were those who would dissolve the Church of England into undogmatic nothing-ness. It was said that he kept two notebooks, one black and one white, into which he entered the names of those of whom he disapproved and approved theologically.

Orthodox church reform along Secker’s lines was, Ingram argues with some passion, a plausible and honourable project in its own time. The only problem is that (as he has to admit) it was utterly doomed.

The Church-state alliance — which, as Ingram points out, was really a Church-Whig alliance — was (as always) an unequal match. All of Secker’s sinuous compromising could not lure the Whig Establishment, profoundly anti-clerical as it was, into honouring the bargain. His dearest project (a bishop for the American colonies) was not worth the potential political cost; the state’s needs in an age of warfare overrode Anglican preferences. The substantial achievements of Secker’s “orthodox church reform” seem very scanty. He could, and did, put the Church’s own house in order, but on the national stage he looks like yet another fall guy for the Establishment.

Ingram tells this dispiriting tale with scholarly caution, but he also has an eye for arresting phrases in his sources. His conclusion, which centres on Secker’s all-but-invisible memorial in a deconsecrated church, is fittingly bleak. But it is his achievement to make us see the 18th century through this all-too-moderate archbishop’s eyes, and even — for a moment — to believe that he might have succeeded.

Dr Ryrie is Reader in the Department of Theology and Religion at Durham University.

To order this book, email the details to Church Times Bookshop (please mention "Church Times Bookshop Price")

Job of the week

Principal

West Midlands

PRINCIPAL ST ALBAN'S ACADEMY Lead an outstanding high-profile school in Birmingham St Alban's Academy serves the Highgate area of Birmingham. It is part of the ARK Schools group, a network of ...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

It’s not all religion’s fault

It’s not all religion’s fault

In her new book, Karen Armstrong argues that violence comes from a deep-seated 'warrior ethos' rather than from religion. She talks to Cole Moreton  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should the seal of the confessional be absolute?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Clergy are ‘more like Old Labour than New’

A survey commissioned to support debates on the future of the C of E yields some interesting results, says Linda Woodhead  Read More

Fri 31 Oct 14 @ 15:11
Canon Alan Billings, Labour Party candidate, elected Police and Crime Commissioner for South Yorkshire. http://t.co/iydy5Z0tDj

Fri 31 Oct 14 @ 14:53
'Positive action' is being taken to create a pool of women ready to be considered for the episcopate http://t.co/mDg7mlOLfo