New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Reviews > Book reviews >

Is there a hole in their buckets?

John Saxbee considers a cumulative case for natural theology

Click to enlarge

The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology
William Lane Craig and J. P. Moreland, editors
Wiley-Blackwell £95
(978-1-4051-7657-6)
Church Times Bookshop £85.50

AT JUST a fiver shy of a ton, this volume is clearly not pitched at the popular end of the market. And so it proves; for, far from journeying with a well-informed and engaging companion, as the title suggests, we are in fact eavesdropping on what feels like an interdisciplinary case conference.

The problem is that for a reader to understand, let alone engage, critically with all or even most of the contributions to this sym­posium, considerable levels of prior knowledge and expertise will be required in maths, physics, astro­nomy, logic, and the natural sciences, let alone philosophy and theology. This is a shame, because the overall enterprise is laudable and timely for all the reasons set out clearly by the editors in their intro­duction.

Natural theology is defined as “the practice of philosophically reflecting on the existence and nature of God independent of real or apparent divine revelation or scripture”. The resurgence in Chris­tian philosophy in general, and natural theology in particular, is attributable to the collapse of positivism and its attendant veri­fication principle of meaning which had rendered metaphysics suspect in respectable philosophical circles.

William Lane Craig and J. P. Moreland are convinced that “theism is on the rise; atheism is on the decline. Atheism . . . is a philo­sophy in retreat.” This somewhat surprising and pugnacious prog­nosis is capped by the claim that “God is not ‘dead’ in academia; he returned to life in the late 1960s and is now alive and well in his last academic stronghold, philosophy departments.”

Although this is written from an American perspective (all but one of the 13 contributors to this sym­po­sium are based in the United States), there is also some ring of truth in relation to British academia as well.

So the scene is set, and the sub­sequent series of substantial essays serves to confirm that natural theo­logy is now a vibrant field of study with specialists in many different disciplines coming to the party.

First of all, Charles Taliaferro emphasises the importance of issues in the philosophy of mind for the viability of natural theology. This allows Richard Dawkins an early appearance as the current high priest of naturalism, allowing no metaphysical accounts of mind, let alone Mind. This physicalist funda­mentalism is virtually dismissed as unworthy of further consideration — and Dawkins leaves the stage.

From here on, the spotlight falls on a series of classical philosophical arguments for the existence of God which do not rely on revelation for their cogency. The cosmological argument of Leibnitz is revisited by Alexander Pruss, while the kalam cosmological argument based on the finitude of the temporal series of past events is revived by William Lane Craig and James D. Sinclair. An acquaintance with quantum physics and string theory would clearly be an advantage here.

Roger Collins’s treatment of the teleological argument makes a strong case for the multiverse hypo­thesis, while arguments from con­sciousness, reason, and morality tread well-worn territory in fresh and challenging ways. Stewart Goetz’s approach to the argument from evil is especially stimulating: understanding the purpose for which persons exist provides the central insight for a viable theo-dicy.

Kai-man Kwan from Hong Kong reasserts the importance of religious experience in justifying theistic beliefs, while Robert E. Maydole offers a densely encrypted account of the ontological argument.

Finally, in a chapter on the argu­ment from miracles, Timothy and Lydia McGrew have the temerity to expose Hulme’s critique as “shallow”, and argue that a cumulative case for the physical resurrection of Jesus is philosophically conclusive.

In fact, the overall dynamic of this Companion is to provide a cumulative case for natural theo­logy, and this approach is always problematic. After all, ten leaky buckets ultimately hold no more water than one leaky bucket; so at least one of the arguments has to be conclusive of itself if the overall cumulative project is to be success­ful.

This point is contested in the book, but without a great deal of conviction. Whether any of these arguments can stand on its own

feet without being resourced to some extent by revelation remains an open question that even this high-powered case conference has not managed to answer conclusively.

Meanwhile, Alister McGrath’s “new vision for natural theology”, The Open Secret(Books, 1 August 2008), offers an intriguing way whereby Christians can use revela­tion to unlock the real potential of natural theology as a resurgent resource in the quest for Truth.

Dr Saxbee is the Bishop of Lincoln.

Order this book through CT Bookshop

Job of the week

Principal

West Midlands

PRINCIPAL ST ALBAN'S ACADEMY Lead an outstanding high-profile school in Birmingham St Alban's Academy serves the Highgate area of Birmingham. It is part of the ARK Schools group, a network of ...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

It’s not all religion’s fault

It’s not all religion’s fault

In her new book, Karen Armstrong argues that violence comes from a deep-seated 'warrior ethos' rather than from religion. She talks to Cole Moreton  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should the seal of the confessional be absolute?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

Clergy are ‘more like Old Labour than New’

A survey commissioned to support debates on the future of the C of E yields some interesting results, says Linda Woodhead  Read More

Fri 31 Oct 14 @ 15:11
Canon Alan Billings, Labour Party candidate, elected Police and Crime Commissioner for South Yorkshire. http://t.co/iydy5Z0tDj

Fri 31 Oct 14 @ 14:53
'Positive action' is being taken to create a pool of women ready to be considered for the episcopate http://t.co/mDg7mlOLfo