New user? Register here:
Email Address:
Password:
Retype Password:
First Name:
Last Name:
Existing user? Login here:
 
 
Comment > Letters to the editor >

Women bishops: reference to the dioceses

From Mr David Lamming
Sir, - At its meeting in London on 11 February, the General Synod will take the revision stage of the new Draft Measure and Amending Canon to enable women to become bishops in the Church of England. This follows the Synod's decision last November that the revision stage should be taken in full Synod, not, as is usual, in a revision committee.

Assuming that the revision stage is completed next month, the next stage will be the referral of the Draft Measure to the dioceses under Article 8. A majority of the 44 diocesan synods must approve the proposals for them to proceed to final approval by the General Synod.

Under standing orders (SOs), the Business Committee has the power to supervise the conduct of the reference, subject to a condition (among others) that diocesan synods shall be informed of the date prescribed by the Committee for replies, "which shall be not less than six months later than the date of the Synod's decision that the matter should be referred" - SO 90(b)(iii).

The timetable for the February sessions has, as an item of business to follow the revision stage: "Motion to suspend SO 90(b)(iii)." No details are given (we are told that "further papers will appear on Friday 17 January"), but the inference must be that the Business Committee intends to impose a shorter period than six months for diocesan synods to respond to the reference. Indeed, it is understood that dioceses have been informed of a proposed deadline of 22 May 2014, presumably with a view to taking the final-approval stage at the Synod meeting in York in July.

While it is entirely understandable that the Synod wishes to proceed swiftly to enacting the new proposals after the débâcle of November 2012, this proposed truncation of the consultation period with dioceses is troubling. Given that many diocesan synods meet in February or March and not again till June, proper consideration of the revised proposals will be difficult, if not impossible. Due process is important if the new Measure is to secure maximum acceptance.

There must also be a doubt whether the proposed suspension of SO 90(b)(iii) would be procedurally proper. SO 38 (which deals with suspension of standing orders), provides that "Any member may move at any time . . . the motion 'That (paragraph . . . of) Standing Order . . . be suspended during (or until) . . .' which may provide for the suspension of one or more Standing Orders (or part of a Standing Order) during the consideration of a particular item of business or until the end of a particular session or group of sessions."

Although widely worded, it is doubtful whether it was ever intended that the SO prescribing the minimum period for diocesan synods to respond to an Article 8 reference should be able to be suspended under this provision.

Giving diocesan synods the prescribed minimum six months to respond to a reference would allow for proper consultation in dioceses, and would still enable the final-approval stage to be taken by the present Synod in November 2014 or February 2015.

DAVID LAMMING
20 Holbrook Barn Road, Boxford
Suffolk CO10 5HU

Job of the week

Ecumenical Chaplain

Wales

G4S An equal opportunities employer Ecumenical Chaplain HMP Parc, Bridgend £29,920 pa | Full time As the world's leading security solutions group with operations in over 120 countries an...  Read More

Signup for job alerts
Top feature

Putting Passion into performance

Putting Passion into performance

Pat Ashworth talks to the originators of two home-grown Passion stagings, one musical and the other theatrical  Subscribe to read more

Question of the week
Should parishes be able to sell treasures that no longer reside in their churches?

To prevent multiple voting, we now ask readers to be logged in. This is free, quick and easy, honestly. Click here to login or register

Top comment

My faith in the Church of England

David Cameron expresses his pride in its openness, beauty, social action, and pastoral care  Read More

Tue 22 Apr 14 @ 22:14
RT @BBCNewsWednesday's Telegraph: "Christians 'afraid to speak up'" http://t.co/ds8REDBnjN #TomorrowsPapersToday #BBCPapers - via @suttonnick

Tue 22 Apr 14 @ 16:30
RT @MuslimCouncilChristianity in Britain: full @MuslimCouncil response to @David_Cameron comments today https://t.co/nag3CNsEta